rare-beanie-buddies

You May Like

Ty Beanie Buddies Snowboy Collectable Beanie Baby was never made. RARE Tags NEW
Ty Beanie Buddies Snowboy Collectable Beanie Baby was never made. RARE Tags NEW

$19.99

View Details
VERY RARE 9.5″ Ty Beanie BUDDY MAGIC the dragon WITH TAGS
VERY RARE 9.5″ Ty Beanie BUDDY MAGIC the dragon WITH TAGS

$130.00

View Details
RARE TY The Beanie Buddies Collection Snowman Stuffed Toy White Black Orange
RARE TY The Beanie Buddies Collection Snowman Stuffed Toy White Black Orange

$100.00

View Details
SUPER RARE Ty Beanie BUDDY Magic the Dragon (9.5 inch) RETIRED Toy Plush READ!
SUPER RARE Ty Beanie BUDDY Magic the Dragon (9.5 inch) RETIRED Toy Plush READ!

$86.88

View Details
"Ty BB Bear Tie Dye Birthday Bear Beanie Buddies Beanie Baby Plush Doll Rare"
"Ty BB Bear Tie Dye Birthday Bear Beanie Buddies Beanie Baby Plush Doll Rare"

$19.99

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddies POOKY Plush Garfield & Characters Bear Santa Hat 2005 RARE 7”
Ty Beanie Buddies POOKY Plush Garfield & Characters Bear Santa Hat 2005 RARE 7”

$35.52

View Details
TY Vintage Christmas Large 1997 Holiday Teddy Beanie Buddy Rare Santa Large
TY Vintage Christmas Large 1997 Holiday Teddy Beanie Buddy Rare Santa Large

$15.00

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddies Plush German Shepherd W/Collar Retired Rare Dog Brown 15" 2000
Ty Beanie Buddies Plush German Shepherd W/Collar Retired Rare Dog Brown 15" 2000

$24.00

View Details
Rare VTG 2000 TY Beanie Buddy Roam Bison Gray White 12 in with Tag (a3)
Rare VTG 2000 TY Beanie Buddy Roam Bison Gray White 12 in with Tag (a3)

$15.00

View Details
Rare Ty Beanie Buddies Extra Large Liberty Libearty USA Retired Patriotic Bear
Rare Ty Beanie Buddies Extra Large Liberty Libearty USA Retired Patriotic Bear

$20.00

View Details
Plush Toys:Ty Beanie Buddy BEARS 2: Rare 14" Bears with Swing Tag-15 USD Each.
Plush Toys:Ty Beanie Buddy BEARS 2: Rare 14" Bears with Swing Tag-15 USD Each.

$15.00

View Details
1999 TY Beanie Buddies 9" Scorch The Dragon Beanie Baby Retired Rare Plush
1999 TY Beanie Buddies 9" Scorch The Dragon Beanie Baby Retired Rare Plush

$9.90

View Details
TY BEANIE BUDDY BUDDIES ORIGINAL 1998 PRINCESS BEAR ERRORS RETIRED #93298
TY BEANIE BUDDY BUDDIES ORIGINAL 1998 PRINCESS BEAR ERRORS RETIRED #93298

$80.00

View Details
RARE TY Beanie Buddy 13” Cat Plush Doll Pink Tag Gray Striped Kitten 1999
RARE TY Beanie Buddy 13” Cat Plush Doll Pink Tag Gray Striped Kitten 1999

$55.00

View Details
TY BEANIE BUDDY 1st GEN ORIGINAL 14in TEDDY THE CRANBERRY BEAR 98 RETIRED ERRORS
TY BEANIE BUDDY 1st GEN ORIGINAL 14in TEDDY THE CRANBERRY BEAR 98 RETIRED ERRORS

$80.00

View Details
RARE RETIRED 1999 Original TY Beanie Buddy Groovy Tie-Dyed Bear ERRORS! Tag Off!
RARE RETIRED 1999 Original TY Beanie Buddy Groovy Tie-Dyed Bear ERRORS! Tag Off!

$39.98

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Teddy Limited Rare Cranberry Color With Tags 14"
Ty Beanie Buddy Teddy Limited Rare Cranberry Color With Tags 14"

$9.60

View Details
1996 Vintage RARE TY Jumbo Papa PJ Chocolate Brown Teddy Bear 60" Plush HUGE
1996 Vintage RARE TY Jumbo Papa PJ Chocolate Brown Teddy Bear 60" Plush HUGE

$299.99

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddies GARFIELD Lying Down * RETIRED * Rare 2006
Ty Beanie Buddies GARFIELD Lying Down * RETIRED * Rare 2006

$15.00

View Details
TY Original Beanie Buddies CLUBBY II 1999 RARE Periwinkle Color
TY Original Beanie Buddies CLUBBY II 1999 RARE Periwinkle Color

$10.53

View Details
TY Beanie Buddies Colosso Purple Elephant Rare 2003 Large Size 12” VGC Pre Owned
TY Beanie Buddies Colosso Purple Elephant Rare 2003 Large Size 12” VGC Pre Owned

$26.99

View Details
ty *RARE* Lot of 3 "PEACE" BEARS - JUMBO/XL, Beanie Buddy & Beanie Baby
ty *RARE* Lot of 3 "PEACE" BEARS - JUMBO/XL, Beanie Buddy & Beanie Baby

$225.00

View Details
TY BEANIE BUDDIES COLLECTION~~SUPER RARE "TWIGS BUDDY"~~MWT'S~~~
TY BEANIE BUDDIES COLLECTION~~SUPER RARE "TWIGS BUDDY"~~MWT'S~~~

$29.95

View Details
RARE Retired Ty Beanie Buddy Buddies YORKIE Dog (YAPPY Instead Of Yapper) 1997
RARE Retired Ty Beanie Buddy Buddies YORKIE Dog (YAPPY Instead Of Yapper) 1997

$7.99

View Details
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddies - Lizzy the Lizard (Tie-Dye) 1999 - Rare & Retired
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddies - Lizzy the Lizard (Tie-Dye) 1999 - Rare & Retired

$19.99

View Details
VTG RARE& HTF Ty Buddy 2000 BATTY- Brown/Pink Bat-MWMT-NEW-wings fasten together
VTG RARE& HTF Ty Buddy 2000 BATTY- Brown/Pink Bat-MWMT-NEW-wings fasten together

$35.95

View Details
TY Beanie Buddy “Ratzo” the Rat - Grey Candy Corn Version *Rare* (13 inch)
TY Beanie Buddy “Ratzo” the Rat - Grey Candy Corn Version *Rare* (13 inch)

$10.00

View Details
Ty 2003 BONSAI Monkey Buddy - Super Soft - 15” RARE
Ty 2003 BONSAI Monkey Buddy - Super Soft - 15” RARE

$14.95

View Details
Ty Vintage Beanie Buddy HUMPHREY the Camel 11" Stuffed Animal Rare Tag Error 98
Ty Vintage Beanie Buddy HUMPHREY the Camel 11" Stuffed Animal Rare Tag Error 98

$70.00

View Details
TY BEANIE BUDDIES BUDDY ORIGINAL PEANUT THE ELEPHANT #9300 RETIRED ERRORS 14"
TY BEANIE BUDDIES BUDDY ORIGINAL PEANUT THE ELEPHANT #9300 RETIRED ERRORS 14"

$60.00

View Details
TY Buddy BATTY, RADAR, BAT-e & BATTY Tan RARE Halloween Bats NWT & tag protector
TY Buddy BATTY, RADAR, BAT-e & BATTY Tan RARE Halloween Bats NWT & tag protector

$149.95

View Details
TY Beanie Buddy **MILLENNIUM** Rare New With Tags RETIRED purple
TY Beanie Buddy **MILLENNIUM** Rare New With Tags RETIRED purple

$10.50

View Details
RARE Ty Classic FOSSILS the Dragon (17 inch) RETIRED Toy Plush READ!
RARE Ty Classic FOSSILS the Dragon (17 inch) RETIRED Toy Plush READ!

$44.88

View Details
REX TIE-DYE BEANIE BUDDY 1999 RARE Tyrannosaurus Plush Toy Retired MINT W/TAG
REX TIE-DYE BEANIE BUDDY 1999 RARE Tyrannosaurus Plush Toy Retired MINT W/TAG

$6.30

View Details
Ty Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Buddy 1998 Rare 15" Inches with Tag
Ty Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Buddy 1998 Rare 15" Inches with Tag

$12.57

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy - Rainbow Sock Monkey (Medium - 16 inch) MWMT - RARE Plush
Ty Beanie Buddy - Rainbow Sock Monkey (Medium - 16 inch) MWMT - RARE Plush

$19.90

View Details
ty Beanie Babies Clubby 1998 “ Stamped “ And Beanie Buddy Clubby 1999 -Rare Set
ty Beanie Babies Clubby 1998 “ Stamped “ And Beanie Buddy Clubby 1999 -Rare Set

$44.87

View Details
Rare TY Beanie Buddy “Peanut" Royal Blue Elephant 1998 With Tag MINT Oakbrook IL
Rare TY Beanie Buddy “Peanut" Royal Blue Elephant 1998 With Tag MINT Oakbrook IL

$14.99

View Details
Ty 1999 Beanie Buddy Amber Kitty Cat Striped Tabby 13" Plush Stuffed RARE
Ty 1999 Beanie Buddy Amber Kitty Cat Striped Tabby 13" Plush Stuffed RARE

$35.00

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Snort the Bull Plush Toy - 4002 Ultra Rare Errors Mint Condition
Ty Beanie Buddy Snort the Bull Plush Toy - 4002 Ultra Rare Errors Mint Condition

$185.00

View Details
Vtg 1998 TY Beanie Baby Buddies collection original STRETCH rare 16" w/ Tag
Vtg 1998 TY Beanie Baby Buddies collection original STRETCH rare 16" w/ Tag

$4.90

View Details
Ty Polar Bear "Chilly" White 1998 Soft Beanie Buddies RARE
Ty Polar Bear "Chilly" White 1998 Soft Beanie Buddies RARE

$18.00

View Details
NWT 2000 TY BEANIE BABY BUDDY FLITTER THE COLORFUL BUTTERFLY RARE & RETIRED
NWT 2000 TY BEANIE BABY BUDDY FLITTER THE COLORFUL BUTTERFLY RARE & RETIRED

$15.00

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Bones 2000 Plush Brown Dog 14 RARE
Ty Beanie Buddy Bones 2000 Plush Brown Dog 14 RARE

$10.00

View Details
TY Beanie Buddy - TWIGS the Giraffe - ( Rare! - 1st Buddy to Retire ) (9 inch)
TY Beanie Buddy - TWIGS the Giraffe - ( Rare! - 1st Buddy to Retire ) (9 inch)

$16.89

View Details
RARE VINTAGE Ty The Beanie Buddies Collection GROOVY the Rainbow Bear 1999
RARE VINTAGE Ty The Beanie Buddies Collection GROOVY the Rainbow Bear 1999

$8.95

View Details
TY Beanie Buddy Black Bat Radar Retired 2001 Halloween Decoration Plush Toy RARE
TY Beanie Buddy Black Bat Radar Retired 2001 Halloween Decoration Plush Toy RARE

$21.00

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddies Hippie Bunny Rabbit 1999 Tie-Dyed Plush LARGE 20" Rare bow
Ty Beanie Buddies Hippie Bunny Rabbit 1999 Tie-Dyed Plush LARGE 20" Rare bow

$39.96

View Details
TY Beanie Buddy Beak 8” Ant Eater Plush Kiwi Bird 1998 Stuffed Animal Rare
TY Beanie Buddy Beak 8” Ant Eater Plush Kiwi Bird 1998 Stuffed Animal Rare

$8.00

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Buddies SWOOP The Pterodactyl 2001 Rare P.E Pellets 8” X 20”
Ty Beanie Buddy Buddies SWOOP The Pterodactyl 2001 Rare P.E Pellets 8” X 20”

$7.50

View Details
Rare Ty Beanie Buddies Pink Peanuts Snoopy Dog Plush Toy 2011 No Sound
Rare Ty Beanie Buddies Pink Peanuts Snoopy Dog Plush Toy 2011 No Sound

$30.00

View Details
Wallace The Bear Ty Beanie Buddies Collection 14 Inch 2000 Retired W Tag Rare
Wallace The Bear Ty Beanie Buddies Collection 14 Inch 2000 Retired W Tag Rare

$14.99

View Details
TY Beanie Buddie RARE WINGLESS QUACKERS Medium 10" Mint 2 Tags One Owner HTF
TY Beanie Buddie RARE WINGLESS QUACKERS Medium 10" Mint 2 Tags One Owner HTF

$80.00

View Details
Rare VTG 2000 TY Beanie Buddy Roam Bison Gray White 12 in with Tag
Rare VTG 2000 TY Beanie Buddy Roam Bison Gray White 12 in with Tag

$7.79

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddies White Tiger 14” Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Laying w/Tags RARE
Ty Beanie Buddies White Tiger 14” Plush Stuffed Animal Toy Laying w/Tags RARE

$9.99

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddies Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant Plush 15" Vintage Rare 1998
Ty Beanie Buddies Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant Plush 15" Vintage Rare 1998

$18.99

View Details
2002 Ty Classic Brown RARE Melvin Moose Plush Beanie Buddies Toy 12” NWT
2002 Ty Classic Brown RARE Melvin Moose Plush Beanie Buddies Toy 12” NWT

$29.99

View Details
RARE Retired Ty Beanie Babies Buddies 1998 Kicks the Soccer Teddy Bear w/ Errors
RARE Retired Ty Beanie Babies Buddies 1998 Kicks the Soccer Teddy Bear w/ Errors

$1200.00

View Details
TY Beanie Buddy Hoppity 14” Bunny Rabbit Plush. Rare And HTF
TY Beanie Buddy Hoppity 14” Bunny Rabbit Plush. Rare And HTF

$24.99

View Details
Rare! Vintage 1998 Beanie Bear Buddies Ty Beanie Babies T-Shirt New! XL
Rare! Vintage 1998 Beanie Bear Buddies Ty Beanie Babies T-Shirt New! XL

$31.49

View Details
⭐️WINGLESS QUACKERS BUDDY⭐️ Rare & HTF! 2007 TY Beanie BUDDY - MWMT'S
⭐️WINGLESS QUACKERS BUDDY⭐️ Rare & HTF! 2007 TY Beanie BUDDY - MWMT'S

$110.00

View Details
RARE Vtg 2000 Ty Beanie Buddies 14" Liberty USA American Bear - MM14
RARE Vtg 2000 Ty Beanie Buddies 14" Liberty USA American Bear - MM14

$12.99

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Peanut The Elephant - Royal Blue VERY RARE!! MWMT!
Ty Beanie Buddy Peanut The Elephant - Royal Blue VERY RARE!! MWMT!

$85.00

View Details
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Rover the Red Dog 1998 Rare Stuffed Animal Plush Toy
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Rover the Red Dog 1998 Rare Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

$2.50

View Details
Rare TY Vintage@2000 Beanie Babies Buddies XL 30" Valentine Red Teddy Bear Plush
Rare TY Vintage@2000 Beanie Babies Buddies XL 30" Valentine Red Teddy Bear Plush

$45.00

View Details
Rare Ty Beanie Baby Rover the Red Dog 1996 and Buddy 1998
Rare Ty Beanie Baby Rover the Red Dog 1996 and Buddy 1998

$25.00

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Buddies tag Colorful Rainbow Sock Monkey 16” 2012 - RARE Plush
Ty Beanie Buddy Buddies tag Colorful Rainbow Sock Monkey 16” 2012 - RARE Plush

$10.00

View Details
Pooky Bear Garfield Holiday Christmas TY Beanie Buddy With Tag • NEW • Rare
Pooky Bear Garfield Holiday Christmas TY Beanie Buddy With Tag • NEW • Rare

$49.95

View Details
Vintage 2001 Ty Beanie Buddies Pounce Kitty Cat 14” Lying Plush! Body Tags RARE!
Vintage 2001 Ty Beanie Buddies Pounce Kitty Cat 14” Lying Plush! Body Tags RARE!

$26.00

View Details
Wallace The Bear Ty Beanie Buddies Collection 14 Inch 2000 Retired W Tag Rare
Wallace The Bear Ty Beanie Buddies Collection 14 Inch 2000 Retired W Tag Rare

$13.25

View Details
RARE 1999 Tiger Furby Buddies - MORE LIGHT Plush Beanie Toy New With Tag.
RARE 1999 Tiger Furby Buddies - MORE LIGHT Plush Beanie Toy New With Tag.

$12.97

View Details
TY BEANIE BUDDY VERY RARE 17" LONG CALICO CAT WHITE PAWS AND CHEST EXCELLENT
TY BEANIE BUDDY VERY RARE 17" LONG CALICO CAT WHITE PAWS AND CHEST EXCELLENT

$12.20

View Details
Ty FROST ARCTIC FOX Beanie Boo Medium Buddy - 9” Rare/Retired Walgreen's Exclu.
Ty FROST ARCTIC FOX Beanie Boo Medium Buddy - 9” Rare/Retired Walgreen's Exclu.

$99.99

View Details
Vintage 2001 TY Beanie Buddies Swoops the Pterodactyl Baby Babies RARE Retired
Vintage 2001 TY Beanie Buddies Swoops the Pterodactyl Baby Babies RARE Retired

$11.99

View Details
Rare Vintage 1998 TY Beanie Buddies Plush Ostrich Stretch Retired 16 inches
Rare Vintage 1998 TY Beanie Buddies Plush Ostrich Stretch Retired 16 inches

$18.73

View Details
TY Beanie Classic Buddy Licorice cat MWMT very rare Blue Bow Discount see Descri
TY Beanie Classic Buddy Licorice cat MWMT very rare Blue Bow Discount see Descri

$99.99

View Details
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Pinky the Flamingo 1998 Rare Stuffed Animal Plush Toy
Vintage Ty Beanie Buddy Pinky the Flamingo 1998 Rare Stuffed Animal Plush Toy

$6.39

View Details
TY Osito Beanie Bear Buddies Collection Rare Red 1999 Retired 14”
TY Osito Beanie Bear Buddies Collection Rare Red 1999 Retired 14”

$9.99

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy “Li Mei” the Panda Bear *Rare* (11 inch)
Ty Beanie Buddy “Li Mei” the Panda Bear *Rare* (11 inch)

$17.99

View Details
Ty BEANIE BUDDY PEANUT Royal Blue 1998 Rare!
Ty BEANIE BUDDY PEANUT Royal Blue 1998 Rare!

$12.99

View Details
"Peanut" Royal Blue Elephant TY Rare Beanie Buddy 1998 PE Pellets Rare New w/Tag
"Peanut" Royal Blue Elephant TY Rare Beanie Buddy 1998 PE Pellets Rare New w/Tag

$10.20

View Details
TY Beanie BUDDY DIPPY EASTER BUNNIE RARE Vintage Patchwork Multi-Color w/Tags!
TY Beanie BUDDY DIPPY EASTER BUNNIE RARE Vintage Patchwork Multi-Color w/Tags!

$19.00

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Peanut The Elephant - Royal Blue VERY RARE!! MWMT!
Ty Beanie Buddy Peanut The Elephant - Royal Blue VERY RARE!! MWMT!

$69.99

View Details
TY Beanie Buddy - QUACKERS without wings; Very Rare 1998
TY Beanie Buddy - QUACKERS without wings; Very Rare 1998

$99.98

View Details
Rare Ty Classic 1997 Beanie Buddy Licorice Plush Black Cat Kitten Red Ribbon
Rare Ty Classic 1997 Beanie Buddy Licorice Plush Black Cat Kitten Red Ribbon

$50.00

View Details
TY Beanie Buddies 2005 "Charming" Blue Pony Horse Braided Rare Retired
TY Beanie Buddies 2005 "Charming" Blue Pony Horse Braided Rare Retired

$12.00

View Details
TY Beanie Buddy Peanut the Elephant RARE 1998
TY Beanie Buddy Peanut the Elephant RARE 1998

$12.00

View Details
TY Cubby IV Beanie Buddy Baby Teddy Bear Retired Rare Find 2001
TY Cubby IV Beanie Buddy Baby Teddy Bear Retired Rare Find 2001

$8.39

View Details
CLUBBY II Bear 1999 Ty Beanie Buddy | Retired and RARE | Mint Condition
CLUBBY II Bear 1999 Ty Beanie Buddy | Retired and RARE | Mint Condition

$11.50

View Details
RARE TY BEANIE BUDDIES- 14" HOLIDAY BEAR-ORIGINAL 2002 BEAR *NICE*
RARE TY BEANIE BUDDIES- 14" HOLIDAY BEAR-ORIGINAL 2002 BEAR *NICE*

$9.99

View Details
Rare Set of Ty Beanie Buddy & Baby Lambs: Chops, Fleece, Fleecie & Fleecia MWMT
Rare Set of Ty Beanie Buddy & Baby Lambs: Chops, Fleece, Fleecie & Fleecia MWMT

$150.00

View Details
TY 1999 Lizzy Ty-dyed TY Beanie Buddy Lizard Amphibian Retired Rare Hard To Find
TY 1999 Lizzy Ty-dyed TY Beanie Buddy Lizard Amphibian Retired Rare Hard To Find

$7.99

View Details
RARE TY Beanie Buddies Buddy XL 42” Valentina Plush Jumbo Teddy Bear With Tag
RARE TY Beanie Buddies Buddy XL 42” Valentina Plush Jumbo Teddy Bear With Tag

$299.98

View Details
2000 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY BUDDY~OLD FACE TEDDY TEAL TEDDY BEAR 14"~NEW!
2000 RARE & RETIRED TY BEANIE BABY BUDDY~OLD FACE TEDDY TEAL TEDDY BEAR 14"~NEW!

$9.34

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Kicks Bear Plush 14" LARGE-RARE- 1999-Retired
Ty Beanie Buddy Kicks Bear Plush 14" LARGE-RARE- 1999-Retired

$17.99

View Details
Ty Beanie Buddy Peanut The Elephant - Royal Blue VERY RARE!! MWMT!
Ty Beanie Buddy Peanut The Elephant - Royal Blue VERY RARE!! MWMT!

$95.00

View Details
ty beanie buddies lot Of 5 Bubbles Ginger Bongo Beak Chilly Large Rare Clean
ty beanie buddies lot Of 5 Bubbles Ginger Bongo Beak Chilly Large Rare Clean

$44.99

View Details
TY Liberty Beanie Buddy 2002 Rare 14 inch with Tags
TY Liberty Beanie Buddy 2002 Rare 14 inch with Tags

$9.00

View Details
TY BEANIE BABY BUDDIES BUDDY ORIGINAL PEKING THE PANDA #9310 RETIRED ERRORS NEW
TY BEANIE BABY BUDDIES BUDDY ORIGINAL PEKING THE PANDA #9310 RETIRED ERRORS NEW

$40.00

View Details
RARE RETIRED 1999 Original TY Beanie Buddy Groovy Tie-Dyed Bear MWMTs & ERRORS!
RARE RETIRED 1999 Original TY Beanie Buddy Groovy Tie-Dyed Bear MWMTs & ERRORS!

$69.00

View Details

© 2008-2024 rare-beanie-buddies (https://www.lumberra.com/). All Rights Reserved.